by G. Sax
I read this blog's comments. Most are interesting and expand upon the conversation. In yesterday's post about porches, there was a comment from a reader named "Bubble_Up" about local housing prices.
The comment didn't have anything to do with porches, but it was cool to see something about Case-Shiller. We have an informed community here, which is good for those of us who like to contribute to the conversation.
So I thought I'd shelve my quirky, neighborhoody banter this week in favor of a chat about the S&P/Case-Shiller Index, the de facto national housing report that reporters flock to.
I'm not interested in debunking Case-Shiller, which some real estatees try to do, including the National Association of REALTORS®. Case-Shiller isn't the real estate devil. It provides a decent snapshot of the American housing market.
The indices were developed by economists Karl Case and Robert Shiller. The 20 largest metro areas are measured using a repeat sales pricing technique to create data pairs; data is collected on single-family home re-sales. The report is produced by Fiserv Lending Services, and many of the indices are managed by Standard & Poor's. (click here to view them)
The Twin Cities took a media beating because of Case-Shiller yesterday. Bubble_Up brought this to our attention with a quote from the St. Paul Pioneer Press: "The report found that home prices in the [Twin Cities] metro area plunged 6.1 percent between February and March, falling back to a level not seen locally since September 2000, according to Case-Shiller." (read full article)
I work in real estate PR, so I took a bunch of calls on Case-Shiller yesterday. The report got the basics right…prices are down here, there and everywhere.
But the increase in Twin Cities foreclosure and short sales activity over the last year wasn't really noted in the first wave of media reports. As the day wore on, we were given a chance to explain our "record decline." More than half of all home sales in the Twin Cities in the first quarter of 2009 involved banks. In April, banks were still in on 46 percent of sales activity, often at deep discounts in already-low price ranges. This drags regional median prices down.
We're backtracking on price, but you're not likely to get a traditional home sale (one with a real person behind the sale and not a bank) at 2000 or even 2002 prices. We're still in tricky waters, for sure, but the situation is more complicated and more localized than Case-Shiller covers.
Foreclosures are selling rapidly and inventory is shrinking. Next year at this time, Case-Shiller may be reporting that we've had record month-over-month increases. And we may be explaining that the increases are statistical anomalies.
In closing, I'm a big fan of porches. I look forward to many summer nights on my front porch listening to Twins games on the radio, waving at neighbors, and watching the sunset wash the Cathedral in shiny orange pinks. All in screened-in luxury!
Comments